Library Sublogic
Module Type Sublogic.
Parameter Inline Tr : Prop -> Prop.
Parameter TrI : ∀ P:Prop, P -> Tr P.
Parameter TrP : ∀ P:Prop, Tr (Tr P) -> Tr P.
Parameter TrMono : ∀ (P Q:Prop), (P->Q)->Tr P->Tr Q.
Notation "# T" := (Tr T).
End Sublogic.
Family of sublogic
Module Type SublogicFamily.
Parameter T : Type.
Parameter Inline Tr : T -> Prop -> Prop.
Parameter TrI : ∀ x (P:Prop), P -> Tr x P.
Parameter TrP : ∀ x (P:Prop), Tr x (Tr x P) -> Tr x P.
Parameter TrMono : ∀ x (P Q:Prop), (P->Q)->Tr x P->Tr x Q.
End SublogicFamily.
Module Type Type_sig. Parameter T : Type. End Type_sig.
Module Type Elt_sig (T:Type_sig). Parameter x : T.T. End Elt_sig.
Module InstSublogicFamily (L:SublogicFamily) (X:Elt_sig L) <: Sublogic.
Import X.
Definition Tr := L.Tr x.
Definition TrI := L.TrI x.
Definition TrP := @L.TrP x.
Definition TrMono := @L.TrMono x.
End InstSublogicFamily.
Module Type ConsistentSublogic.
Include Sublogic.
Parameter TrCons : ~ Tr False.
End ConsistentSublogic.
Parameter T : Type.
Parameter Inline Tr : T -> Prop -> Prop.
Parameter TrI : ∀ x (P:Prop), P -> Tr x P.
Parameter TrP : ∀ x (P:Prop), Tr x (Tr x P) -> Tr x P.
Parameter TrMono : ∀ x (P Q:Prop), (P->Q)->Tr x P->Tr x Q.
End SublogicFamily.
Module Type Type_sig. Parameter T : Type. End Type_sig.
Module Type Elt_sig (T:Type_sig). Parameter x : T.T. End Elt_sig.
Module InstSublogicFamily (L:SublogicFamily) (X:Elt_sig L) <: Sublogic.
Import X.
Definition Tr := L.Tr x.
Definition TrI := L.TrI x.
Definition TrP := @L.TrP x.
Definition TrMono := @L.TrMono x.
End InstSublogicFamily.
Module Type ConsistentSublogic.
Include Sublogic.
Parameter TrCons : ~ Tr False.
End ConsistentSublogic.
Sublogics are monads
Module AlternativeFormulations.
Module Type LogicMonad.
Parameter Inline M : Prop -> Prop.
Parameter ret : ∀ P:Prop, P -> M P.
Parameter bind : ∀ P Q:Prop, M P -> (P -> M Q) -> M Q.
End LogicMonad.
Module SublogicToMonad (M:LogicMonad) : Sublogic with Definition Tr := M.M.
Import M.
Definition Tr := M.
Definition TrI (P:Prop) (p:P) : Tr P := ret p.
Definition TrP (P:Prop) (p:Tr(Tr P)) : Tr P := bind p (fun x => x).
Definition TrMono (P Q:Prop) (f:P->Q) (p:Tr P) : Tr Q :=
bind p (fun x => ret (f x)).
End SublogicToMonad.
Module MonadToSublogic (L:Sublogic) : LogicMonad with Definition M := L.Tr.
Import L.
Definition M := Tr.
Definition ret (P:Prop) (p:P) : M P := TrI p.
Definition bind (P Q:Prop) (p:Tr P) (f:P->Tr Q) : Tr Q :=
TrP (TrMono f p).
End MonadToSublogic.
End AlternativeFormulations.
Module Type LogicMonad.
Parameter Inline M : Prop -> Prop.
Parameter ret : ∀ P:Prop, P -> M P.
Parameter bind : ∀ P Q:Prop, M P -> (P -> M Q) -> M Q.
End LogicMonad.
Module SublogicToMonad (M:LogicMonad) : Sublogic with Definition Tr := M.M.
Import M.
Definition Tr := M.
Definition TrI (P:Prop) (p:P) : Tr P := ret p.
Definition TrP (P:Prop) (p:Tr(Tr P)) : Tr P := bind p (fun x => x).
Definition TrMono (P Q:Prop) (f:P->Q) (p:Tr P) : Tr Q :=
bind p (fun x => ret (f x)).
End SublogicToMonad.
Module MonadToSublogic (L:Sublogic) : LogicMonad with Definition M := L.Tr.
Import L.
Definition M := Tr.
Definition ret (P:Prop) (p:P) : M P := TrI p.
Definition bind (P Q:Prop) (p:Tr P) (f:P->Tr Q) : Tr Q :=
TrP (TrMono f p).
End MonadToSublogic.
End AlternativeFormulations.
Sublogic equipped with tools useful for doing logics
Module Type SublogicTheory.
Include Sublogic.
Definition isL (P:Prop) := Tr P -> P.
Global Instance Tr_morph : Proper (iff==>iff) Tr.
Admitted.
Global Instance isL_morph : Proper (iff==>iff) isL.
Admitted.
Parameter TrB : ∀ (P Q:Prop), Tr P -> (P -> Tr Q) -> Tr Q.
Parameter Tr_ind : ∀ (P Q:Prop) {i:isL Q}, (P -> Q) -> Tr P -> Q.
The set of L-propositions: introduction rules
Parameter Tr_isL : ∀ P, isL (Tr P).
Parameter T_isL : ∀ P:Prop, P -> isL P.
Parameter and_isL : ∀ P Q, isL P -> isL Q -> isL (P/\Q).
Parameter fa_isL : ∀ A (P:A->Prop),
(∀ x, isL (P x)) -> isL(∀ x, P x).
Parameter imp_isL : ∀ P Q, isL Q -> isL (P -> Q).
Parameter iff_isL : ∀ P Q, isL P -> isL Q -> isL (P <-> Q).
Global Hint Resolve Tr_isL T_isL and_isL fa_isL imp_isL iff_isL.
Parameter rFF : ∀ (Q:Prop), Tr False -> Tr Q.
Parameter rFF': ∀ (Q:Prop), Tr False -> isL Q -> Q.
Parameter T_isL : ∀ P:Prop, P -> isL P.
Parameter and_isL : ∀ P Q, isL P -> isL Q -> isL (P/\Q).
Parameter fa_isL : ∀ A (P:A->Prop),
(∀ x, isL (P x)) -> isL(∀ x, P x).
Parameter imp_isL : ∀ P Q, isL Q -> isL (P -> Q).
Parameter iff_isL : ∀ P Q, isL P -> isL Q -> isL (P <-> Q).
Global Hint Resolve Tr_isL T_isL and_isL fa_isL imp_isL iff_isL.
Parameter rFF : ∀ (Q:Prop), Tr False -> Tr Q.
Parameter rFF': ∀ (Q:Prop), Tr False -> isL Q -> Q.
Introduction tactics
Ltac Tin := apply TrI.
Ltac Texists t := Tin; exists t.
Ltac Tleft := Tin; left.
Ltac Tright := Tin; right.
Elimination tactics:
- Tabsurd replaces the current goal with Tr False (ex-falso)
- Telim H implements rules H:Tr P |- G --> |- P->G when G is a L-prop
- Tdestruct H is the equivalent of destruct on a hypothesis Tr(Ind x). The goal shall be an L-prop
Ltac prove_isL :=
intros;
lazymatch goal with
| |- isL(Tr _) => apply Tr_isL
| |- isL(_ /\ _) => apply and_isL; prove_isL
| |- isL True => apply T_isL; exact I
| |- isL(impl _ _) => apply imp_isL; prove_isL
| |- isL(iff _ _) => apply iff_isL; prove_isL
| |- isL(_ -> _) => apply imp_isL; prove_isL
| |- isL(∀ x, _) => apply fa_isL; intro; prove_isL
| |- isL _ => auto 10; fail "Cannot prove isL side-condition"
| |- _ => fail "Tactic prove_isL does not apply to this goal"
end.
Ltac Tabsurd :=
lazymatch goal with
| |- Tr _ => apply rFF
| |- _ => apply rFF';[|auto 10;fail"Cannot prove isL side-condition"]
end.
Ltac Telim H :=
lazymatch goal with
| |- Tr _ => apply TrB with (1:=H); try clear H
| |- _ => apply Tr_ind with (3:=H);[auto 10;fail"Cannot prove isL side-condition"|]; try clear H
end.
Tactic Notation "Tdestruct" constr(H) :=
Telim H; destruct 1.
Tactic Notation "Tdestruct" constr(H) "as" simple_intropattern(p) :=
Telim H; intros p.
End SublogicTheory.
Module BuildLogic (L:Sublogic) <: SublogicTheory.
Include L.
Derived sublogic concepts:
- more elimination rules (bind of the monad)
- the set of L-propositions
Global Instance Tr_morph : Proper (iff==>iff) Tr.
Qed.
Definition isL (P:Prop) := Tr P -> P.
Global Instance isL_morph : Proper (iff==>iff) isL.
Qed.
Lemma TrB : ∀ (P Q:Prop), Tr P -> (P -> Tr Q) -> Tr Q.
Lemma Tr_ind : ∀ (P Q:Prop) {i:isL Q}, (P -> Q) -> Tr P -> Q.
The set of L-propositions: introduction rules.
L-props are closed under all connectives of negative
polarity.
Lemma Tr_isL : ∀ P, isL (Tr P).
Lemma T_isL : ∀ P:Prop, P -> isL P.
Lemma and_isL : ∀ P Q, isL P -> isL Q -> isL (P/\Q).
Lemma fa_isL : ∀ A (P:A->Prop),
(∀ x, isL (P x)) -> isL(∀ x, P x).
Lemma imp_isL : ∀ P Q, isL Q -> isL (P -> Q).
Lemma iff_isL : ∀ P Q, isL P -> isL Q -> isL (P <-> Q).
Global Hint Resolve Tr_isL T_isL and_isL fa_isL imp_isL iff_isL.
Elimination rules for falsity
Lemma rFF (Q:Prop) : Tr False -> Tr Q.
Lemma rFF' (Q:Prop) : Tr False -> isL Q -> Q.
End BuildLogic.
The same for consistent logics: False is now an L-prop
Module BuildConsistentSublogic (L:ConsistentSublogic).
Module tmp <: SublogicTheory := BuildLogic L.
Include tmp.
Lemma FF_isL : isL False.
Global Hint Resolve FF_isL.
End BuildConsistentSublogic.
Module CoqSublogic <: ConsistentSublogic.
Definition Tr P:Prop := P.
Definition TrI (P:Prop) (p:P) : Tr P := p.
Definition TrP (P:Prop) (p:Tr (Tr P)) : Tr P := p.
Definition TrMono (P Q:Prop) (f:P->Q) (p:Tr P) : Tr Q := f p.
Definition TrCons : ~ Tr False := fun h => h.
End CoqSublogic.
Module CoqSublogicThms := BuildConsistentSublogic CoqSublogic.
Definition Tr P:Prop := P.
Definition TrI (P:Prop) (p:P) : Tr P := p.
Definition TrP (P:Prop) (p:Tr (Tr P)) : Tr P := p.
Definition TrMono (P Q:Prop) (f:P->Q) (p:Tr P) : Tr Q := f p.
Definition TrCons : ~ Tr False := fun h => h.
End CoqSublogic.
Module CoqSublogicThms := BuildConsistentSublogic CoqSublogic.
Module ClassicSublogic <: ConsistentSublogic.
Definition Tr (P:Prop) := ~~P.
Definition TrI (P:Prop) (p:P) : Tr P := fun np => np p.
Definition TrP (P:Prop) (nnnnp:Tr (Tr P)) : Tr P :=
fun np => nnnnp (fun nnp => nnp np).
Definition TrMono (P Q:Prop) (f:P->Q) (nnp:Tr P) : Tr Q :=
fun nq => nnp (fun p => nq (f p)).
Definition TrCons : ~ Tr False := fun h => h (fun x => x).
End ClassicSublogic.
Module ClassicSublogicThms.
Include BuildConsistentSublogic ClassicSublogic.
Lemma nnpp (P:Prop) : ((P->False)->False) -> Tr P.
Definition Tr (P:Prop) := ~~P.
Definition TrI (P:Prop) (p:P) : Tr P := fun np => np p.
Definition TrP (P:Prop) (nnnnp:Tr (Tr P)) : Tr P :=
fun np => nnnnp (fun nnp => nnp np).
Definition TrMono (P Q:Prop) (f:P->Q) (nnp:Tr P) : Tr Q :=
fun nq => nnp (fun p => nq (f p)).
Definition TrCons : ~ Tr False := fun h => h (fun x => x).
End ClassicSublogic.
Module ClassicSublogicThms.
Include BuildConsistentSublogic ClassicSublogic.
Lemma nnpp (P:Prop) : ((P->False)->False) -> Tr P.
excluded-middle: note that P need not be classical, which makes the
positive case stronger.
Module ASublogic <: SublogicFamily.
Definition T:=Prop.
Definition Tr A P := P \/ A.
Definition TrI (A P:Prop) (p:P) : Tr A P := or_introl p.
Definition TrP (A P:Prop) (p:(P\/A)\/A) :=
match p with
| or_introl p => p
| or_intror a => or_intror a
end.
Definition TrMono (A P Q:Prop) (f:P->Q) (p:P\/A) :=
match p with
| or_introl p => or_introl (f p)
| or_intror a => or_intror a
end.
End ASublogic.
Module Type Aprop. Parameter x:Prop. End Aprop.
Module ASublogicThms (A:Aprop) <: SublogicTheory.
Module Asl := InstSublogicFamily ASublogic A.
Import Asl.
Notation A := A.x.
Include BuildLogic Asl.
Lemma Aconsistency : isL False <-> ~A.
Lemma atom_isL (P:Prop) : (A->P) -> isL P.
or does not need to be modified
existential does need to be modified when one of the
instances is an L-prop.
A more usable rule (we can expect the forall x, isL (P x)
assumption to be provable automatically), but which requires T to
be inhabited.
Lemma ex_isL T (P:T->Prop) :
T -> (∀ x, isL (P x)) -> isL (ex P).
Global Hint Resolve ex_isL.
Lemma FF_a : Tr False <-> A.
End ASublogicThms.
T -> (∀ x, isL (P x)) -> isL (ex P).
Global Hint Resolve ex_isL.
Lemma FF_a : Tr False <-> A.
End ASublogicThms.
Example: if ~~exists x. P(x) is derivable, then so is exists x. P(x)
Module AtransExample.
Parameter (T:Type) (P : T->Prop).
Module nnex. Definition x:=exists x, P x. End nnex.
Module Atr := ASublogicThms nnex.
Import nnex Atr.
Lemma markov_rule :
((Tr(exists x, P x) -> Tr False) -> Tr False) ->
exists x, P x.
End AtransExample.
Parameter (T:Type) (P : T->Prop).
Module nnex. Definition x:=exists x, P x. End nnex.
Module Atr := ASublogicThms nnex.
Import nnex Atr.
Lemma markov_rule :
((Tr(exists x, P x) -> Tr False) -> Tr False) ->
exists x, P x.
End AtransExample.
Module PeirceTrans <: SublogicFamily.
Definition T := Prop.
Definition Tr (R A:Prop) := (A->R)->A.
Definition TrI (R A:Prop) (a:A) : Tr R A := fun ar => a.
Definition TrP (R A:Prop) (tta:Tr R (Tr R A)) : Tr R A :=
fun ar => tta (fun ara => ar (ara ar)) ar.
Definition TrMono (R A B:Prop) (f:A->B) (ta:Tr R A) : Tr R B :=
fun br => f (ta (fun a => br (f a))).
Definition TrCons (R:Prop) : ~ Tr R False :=
fun frf => frf (False_ind R).
End PeirceTrans.
Module PeirceSublogicThms (A:Aprop) <: SublogicTheory.
Module Psl := InstSublogicFamily PeirceTrans A.
Import Psl.
Notation A := A.x.
Include BuildLogic Psl.
Lemma Pconsistency : isL False.
End PeirceSublogicThms.
Module Inter (L:SublogicFamily) <: Sublogic.
Definition Tr P := ∀ x, L.Tr x P.
Definition TrI (P:Prop) (p:P) : Tr P := fun x => L.TrI x p.
Definition TrP (P:Prop) (ttp:Tr(Tr P)) : Tr P :=
fun x => L.TrP (L.TrMono (fun p => p x) (ttp x)).
Definition TrMono (P Q:Prop) (f:P->Q) (p:Tr P) : Tr Q :=
fun x => L.TrMono f (p x).
Lemma equiCons : Tr False <-> ∀ x, L.Tr x False.
End Inter.
Module Inter2 (L1 L2:Sublogic) <: Sublogic.
Definition Tr P := L1.Tr P /\ L2.Tr P.
Definition TrI (P:Prop) (p:P) : Tr P := conj (L1.TrI p) (L2.TrI p).
Definition TrP (P:Prop) (ttp:Tr(Tr P)) : Tr P :=
conj (L1.TrP (L1.TrMono (fun p => proj1 p) (proj1 ttp)))
(L2.TrP (L2.TrMono (fun p => proj2 p) (proj2 ttp))).
Definition TrMono (P Q:Prop) (f:P->Q) (p:Tr P) : Tr Q :=
conj (L1.TrMono f (proj1 p)) (L2.TrMono f (proj2 p)).
Lemma equiCons : Tr False <-> L1.Tr False /\ L2.Tr False.
Lemma isL_intro P : (L1.Tr P -> P) \/ (L2.Tr P -> P) -> (Tr P -> P).
End Inter2.
Module SublogicToHOLogic (L:SublogicTheory) <: HOLogic.
Import L.
Record prop_ := mkP { holds : Prop; isprop : isL holds }.
Definition prop := prop_.
Definition TT : prop.
exists True; auto.
Defined.
Definition FF : prop.
exists (Tr False); trivial.
Defined.
Definition Imp (P Q:prop) : prop.
exists (holds P->holds Q).
Defined.
Definition Not p := Imp p FF.
Definition And (P Q:prop) : prop.
exists (holds P /\ holds Q).
Defined.
Definition Or (P Q:prop) : prop.
exists (Tr(holds P \/ holds Q)).
Defined.
Definition Forall {A} (P:A->prop) : prop.
exists (∀ x, holds (P x)).
Defined.
Definition Exist {A} (P:A->prop) : prop.
exists (Tr(exists x, holds (P x))).
Defined.
Definition Ex2 {A} (P Q:A->prop) : prop.
exists (Tr(exists2 x, holds (P x) & holds (Q x))).
Defined.
Inference rules
Lemma rTT : holds TT.
Lemma rFF P : holds FF -> holds P.
Lemma rAnd P Q : holds (And P Q) <-> holds P /\ holds Q.
Lemma rImp P Q : holds (Imp P Q) <-> (holds P -> holds Q).
Lemma rForall A P : holds (Forall P) <-> ∀ x:A, holds (P x).
Lemma rNot P : holds (Not P) <-> (holds P -> holds FF).
Lemma rOrI P Q : holds P \/ holds Q -> holds (Or P Q).
Lemma rOrE P Q C : (holds P \/ holds Q -> holds C) -> holds (Or P Q) -> holds C.
Lemma rExI A P : (exists (x:A), holds (P x)) -> holds (Exist P).
Lemma rExE A P C : (∀ x:A, holds (P x) -> holds C) -> holds (Exist P) -> holds C.
Lemma rEx2I A (P Q:A->prop) : (exists2 x, holds (P x) & holds (Q x)) -> holds (Ex2 P Q).
Lemma rEx2E A P Q C : (∀ x:A, holds (P x) -> holds (Q x) -> holds C) -> holds (Ex2 P Q) -> holds C.
Lemma equiCons : Tr False <-> holds FF.
End SublogicToHOLogic.